AI AI Toolkit
AI Newsindustry

OpenAI 汇编各方法庭之友意见,主张 AI 训练应适用合理使用原则

OpenAI:官网动态(RSS · 排除企业/客户案例)2026-10-30T00:00:00.000Z

Key Highlights

On October 30 OpenAI published a long post, "Fair use benefits everyone," compiling excerpts from amicus briefs submitted to the court by law professors, the Authors Alliance, the Association of Research Libraries, the American Council of the Blind, and the U.S. government. The central argument is singular: using copyrighted works to train large models is transformative use protected under the fair use doctrine, and it is vital to the public interest and innovation.

What Happened

The post directly answers The New York Times' lawsuit against OpenAI. The plaintiff seeks to expand copyright protection to exclude fair use in AI training; OpenAI and its supporters counter that this ignores half a century of legal precedent and sacrifices the public good for unwarranted damages. Using fair use as the fulcrum, OpenAI reframes the case as "innovation versus monopoly."

Technical Details

Law professor Matthew Sag and others note that training a foundation model aims not to reproduce the source but to build a general-purpose tool, and its outputs are not similar to the invisible intermediate copies used in training, strongly supporting a fair-use finding. The Authors Alliance stresses that copyright guards against "expressiveness substitution," not "market competition," so alleged "market dilution" is not a cognizable harm. The U.S. government warned in its brief that excluding LLM training from fair use would severely impede "the progress of science and useful arts."

Versus Competitors

Aligned with Anthropic and Meta, which face similar copyright suits, OpenAI frames fair use as an existential industry issue. The difference is emphasis: OpenAI leans on "benefiting the disadvantaged" — the blind, independent creators, farmers and medical researchers would all be harmed by training restrictions — packaging a commercial stance as inclusive value.

Industry Impact and Use Cases

For AI companies and content creators alike, this legal battle will shape the content ecosystem for the next decade. If the court adopts the fair-use position, the data cost and legal risk of model training drop sharply; if the plaintiff wins, every training run could trigger astronomical damages. Either way, a data-licensing market — like Reddit's deal with Google — becomes a new monetization path for rights holders.

Practical Notes

The strategic craft here is coalition-building. By quoting law professors, libraries, disability advocates, and the government rather than speaking only in its own voice, OpenAI borrows credibility and reframes a self-interested position as a public-interest one. For observers, the takeaway is that the fair-use argument rests on a specific factual claim — that training copies are invisible intermediates, not substitutable expressions — and that claim, not rhetoric, is what the court will test.

What to Watch

Two uncertainties. First, the "market dilution" argument may evolve: rights holders could pivot from claiming substitution to claiming harm to a licensing market that fair use itself prevents from forming. Second, even a fair-use win at the federal level may not settle everything — statutory damages, state-law claims, and non-U.S. jurisdictions each carve out their own terrain, so global operators should expect a patchwork rather than a clean resolution.

Closing

This post is less a legal brief than a mobilization memo. OpenAI is assembling the widest possible coalition to normalize the idea that training on copyrighted works is not theft but progress. Whether the courts agree will decide not just OpenAI's balance sheet but the default permission regime for the entire generative-AI industry — which is exactly why so many parties are weighing in.

The Bigger Picture

Step back and the post is a data point in a larger realignment: the AI industry is moving from "ask forgiveness" to "build the legal and normative case in public." Training on copyrighted works is now openly defended as a public good rather than quietly assumed, and that rhetorical shift matters because the eventual rule will be shaped by who frames the debate first. For content creators, the uncomfortable implication is that the default may tilt toward permissive training unless rights holders organize a coherent counter-narrative of their own. The briefs collected here are less about one lawsuit than about setting the terms for the next decade of how models are fed. The practical upshot is that the fairness of training is no longer a fringe academic question but a board-level risk that every AI company, and every publisher, now has to price into its strategy and its balance sheet.